It ’s been a tumultuous few twelvemonth for Pluto . The gnome major planet , first discovered in 1930 by astronomer Clyde Tombaugh , wasstrippedof its more esteemed planet status in 2006 by the International Astronomical Union ( IAU ) because its orbit overlap that of Neptune . A new set of IAU criterion mandated that a major planet must orbit the sun , be globose as a result of sobriety , and " clear " the " neighborhood " around its orbit , put forward itself as the dominant bearing . Pluto met the first and second edicts but not the third , relegating it to the lesser gnome planet designation .

That resolution led to an ongoing disputation over whether Pluto really earn its demotion . The newest and potentially most compelling argument issue forth courtesy of apaperfrom researchers at the University of Central Florida ’s Space Institute and put out in the planetary science journalIcarus . In it , first writer Philip Metzger asserts that no one since 1802 has used the discharge - space argument to define a planet . Referring to the IAU ’s definition as " sloppy , " Metzger and his conscientious objector - writer point out that no one else has separated asteroid from planets by using the glade mandate . Planets , the composition argues , should not be apply to dynamical descriptions of bodies that may alter over time .

" We now have a list of well over 100 late example of planetary scientist using the word planet in a direction that violate the IAU definition , but they are doing it because it ’s functionally utilitarian , " Metzger sound out in astatement . " It ’s a sloppy definition . They did n’t say what they intend by clear their scope . If you take that literally , then there are no planets , because no planet clear its orbit . "

iStock

Metzger is advocate instead for a planet obtain its status due to being orotund enough to reach a gravity - determine spherical frame that activate geological change .

Speaking withCNN , IAU voice Lars Lindberg Christensen bespeak a motion could be put forward to have the group reevaluate the categorization but that no one had yet done so .

Whatever Pluto is or may one day become , it was a major planet to Tombaugh , who was n’t around long enough to experience the reclassification . He died in 1997 . In 2015 , his ash tree , attached to the New Horizons quad probe , enteredPluto ’s arena after nine age of travel .

[ h / tScience Alert ]