Turns out, the actress, 32 — who has a 16-month-old son, Cy, with her husband, art galleristCooke Maroney— has her own strange Craigslist story, she tells PEOPLE.
“Years ago, Lee Eisenberg bought a toilet on Craigslist from my mom. My toilet,” says Lawrence. Eisenberg is the writing partner ofNo Hard Feelingsdirector Gene Stupnitsky.
The revelation elicited a “woah,” from Lawrence’s costar Feldman (of Broadway’sDear Evan Hansen), who joined her for the interview.

So why was Lawrence’s mother, Karen, selling a toilet on Craigslist? “I don’t know,” says Lawrence. “I’m like, ‘I broke it.’ My mom sold it for me.” She adds that Eisenberg knew the identity of the seller at the time he purchased the bathroom fixture. “That’s how we know the story now,” she says. “So thanks, Mom.”
Eisenberg, who co-wrote the 2011 Cameron Diaz hitBad Teacherwith Stupnitsky, has not yet responded to PEOPLE’s request for comment.
Pascal Le Segretain/Getty

Still, she acknowledged to60 Minutesin 2018 that Karen and Gary made sacrifices for her career. “My parents, you know—changed their entire lives to support me,” she said.
Sony Pictures Entertainment/YouTube

In the same interview, Lawrence said was a “weirdo” who used to lie at school and tell her teachers and classmates that she had a wooden leg. “And I, like, walked in a very consistent limp. Like, incredibly consistent. And when my mom came to get me from school, my teachers were, like, ‘It’s awful what happened to Jennifer’s leg.’ And my mom was, like, ‘She does not have—she’s—her leg has not been amputated.’ I used to just invent stories just to invent them.”
Her antics back then could get the best of her folks. “My parents were just—you know, they would go through periods of time where they just wanted me outta the house. And it was called a lockout. And so I’d go to the door and it was locked. And I’d be like all right. I gotta find something else to do until my parents were ready to deal with me again,” she continued.
John Phillips/Getty

“I was a handful. And I got it. We never fought about it. I’ve always been very self-aware about my annoyingness,” said Lawrence.
Though she may consider herself annoying, the actress tells PEOPLE she was concerned any potential costar inNo Hard Feelingswould drive her crazy, too. “I was very worried that my young co-star was going to annoy me all day, every day. Immediately, I sussed out. I was like, Okay, this is not an annoying person,’” she says of Feldman.
The two bonded and became friends during the shoot, with Lawrence even offering her young costar advice about being in show business. “I tried to keep my advice technical, because he is just a nice person that’s just a genuinely kind person, and so I thought it would be annoying to say what everybody always said to me, ‘Don’t change,’ because he’s not going to change. He’s a wonderful, sweet person, but I was like, ‘You need to get a stylist, you need to get a publicist.’”
No Hard Feelingsis in theaters nationwide Friday, June 23.
For more on Jennifer Lawrence, pick up the new issue of PEOPLE.
source: people.com